Skip to main content

The best accommodation in Long Island

Check out our pick of great accommodation in Long Island

Filter by:


Review score

Superb: 9+ Very good: 8+ Good: 7+ Pleasant: 6+
Our top picks Lowest price first Star rating and price Top reviewed

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.

Set in Greenport, 41 km from Splish Splash, Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows offers accommodation with free bikes, free private parking, a garden and a private beach area. With free WiFi, this 4-star hotel has a restaurant and a bar. Some units at the property feature a patio with a sea view. It‘s a very nice place with Great attention to Details. Everyone who worked there, in the Hotel, the bar and in the Diner, were very friendly, helpful and accommodating. It felt like you had been a guest many times before

Show more Show less
9.6
Exceptional
110 reviews
Price from
US$290
per night

Set in Hampton Bays in the New York region with Meschutt Beach nearby, Aria & Mare Hamptons offers accommodation with free private parking, as well as access to a hot tub. The property has sea views and is 27 km from Splish Splash and 43 km from Montauk Point Lighthouse. Karen, Juan and Luca are amazing and lovely hosts, who do everything necessary to make the stay perfect. Breakfast offers everything you could wish for. The accommodation is beautiful and interior is super nice with super nice details. The house is just located in front of the water close to Southampton and many nice restaurants close by.

Show more Show less
9.6
Exceptional
103 reviews
Price from
US$357.50
per night

Offering inner courtyard views, The 1708 House is an accommodation set in Southampton, 2.2 km from Gin Beach and 34 km from Montauk Point Lighthouse. This property offers access to a patio, a pool table, free private parking and free WiFi. The bed and breakfast offers garden views and a sun terrace. This property blew me away. The amenities and decor were top notch.

Show more Show less
9.7
Exceptional
166 reviews
Price from
US$275
per night

Located in Garden City and with Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum reachable within 4.1 km, Residence Inn Long Island Garden City provides express check-in and check-out, non-smoking rooms, a fitness centre, free WiFi throughout the property and a shared lounge. This 3-star hotel offers a 24-hour front desk and a business centre. The hotel has a barbecue and an indoor pool.

You can play billiards at the accommodation. location- rooms size- free parking- clean and comfortable beds

Show more Show less
9.1
Superb
240 reviews
Price from
US$219.88
per night

Boasting a terrace, bar and views of city, The Menhaden Hotel is situated in Greenport, 41 km from Splish Splash. Featuring free bikes, the 4-star hotel has air-conditioned rooms with free WiFi, each with a private bathroom. The accommodation features a 24-hour front desk, a concierge service and luggage storage for guests. From the self service breakfast and tea time in the evenings, the kitchenette was amazing. The rooms are spacious, lovely interior and exterior. The rooftop lounge and bar is just that cherry on top. They have a cafe and small shop with all your holiday essentials within the hotel which is incredibly convenient. The staff was incredible as well, would like to especially point out Mario (the manager), Dan (the bartender), Aedan (the receptionist), and Alfred (the room service expert).

Show more Show less
9.4
Superb
112 reviews
Price from
US$309
per night

American Beech Hotel has free bikes, garden, a restaurant and bar in Greenport. This 4-star hotel offers free WiFi. The property is allergy-free and is situated 42 km from Splish Splash.

Long Island Railroad is 27 km from the accommodation. Long Island MacArthur Airport is 77 km from the property. Breakfast was fine, would be nice to switch it up a bit so its not all the same each consecutive day. Love the spot, the outdoor areas and bar. We stop here every time were in Greenport, although this is the first time we stayed overnight.

Show more Show less
9.1
Superb
143 reviews
Price from
US$250.80
per night

Situated in Hampton Bays, 24 km from Splish Splash, Colonial Shores Resort features accommodation with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free private parking, a garden and a terrace. Boasting family rooms, this property also provides guests with a children's playground. The accommodation provides room service and free WiFi throughout the property. We loved our cottage ,so clean and nearby everything. Kitchen w Mr Coffee maker plus coffee for next morning was perfect. As was the super clean fridge and bathroom. Appreciated the quiet.

Show more Show less
9.1
Superb
113 reviews
Price from
US$245
per night

This Montauk hotel is located directly across from the beach and boasts an outdoor heated pool and rooms with a terrace. Montauk village is .5 miles away.

Hither Hills State Park is 5 miles from the hotel. Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course is 10 minutes’ drive away. Liz and her staff are beyond exceptional. Lovely Erica at reception. Voldy at the pool always had a smile- extra towels, sunscreen. Tennis court has pickleball lines too. In pristine condition. Easy sign up sheet. Change over/ room care teams are thorough and efficient. With crisp white cotton sheets. Pillows are soft. Ice machine working well. Grounds beautifully maintained. Lovely new logos and stickers - little touches do matter. Just look at how many guests are repeat customers - that says it all.

Show more Show less
9.1
Superb
167 reviews
Price from
US$220.39
per night

This Montauk resort offers free Wi-Fi, a seasonal outdoor pool, and accommodations that feature a living area with sofa bed and a flat-screen TV. Kirk Park Beach is half a mile away.

Accommodations include bright decor and ocean views. Select housing at Plum Resort includes a fireplace and a full kitchen that offers a hob, microwave, and refrigerator. I like that the front desk is so welcoming. View and the room is amazing! Proximity to the beach is the reason you book this place.

Show more Show less
9
Superb
169 reviews
Price from
US$219.70
per night

This Montauk motel is opposite the beach, and boat rentals are available a mile away at Fort Pond. The Hither Hills State Park is located 3 miles from the property.

Hartman’s Briney Breezes Motel offers free Wi-Fi throughout the property. They also have an outdoor heated pool, picnic areas and BBQ facilities available for guests. Amazing location, super quick walk to the beach! All the rooms have balconies with seating that looks out on the water. Very lovely all around. The kitchens has everything you will need - full fridge, stove, oven, microwave, etc. There is also a large lawn with tons of grills, picnics tables, chairs, umbrellas, and cornhole. The owners were fantastic, very accommodating and helpful. No complaints!

Show more Show less
9.1
Superb
140 reviews
Price from
US$195
per night

Most booked accommodation in Long Island this month

FAQs about accommodation in Long Island

Accommodation that guests love in Long Island