Skip to main content

The best homestays in Long Island

Check out our pick of great homestays in Long Island

Filter by:


Review score

Superb: 9+ Very good: 8+ Good: 7+ Pleasant: 6+
Our top picks Lowest price first Star rating and price Top reviewed

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.

This homestay will provide guests with a cable flat-screen TV, a seating area and an iPad. Towels and bed linen are provided in the homestay. For added privacy, the accommodation has a private entrance and is protected by full-day security. It was a such nice and quite place in a really good area!! I recommitted!!!

Show more Show less
9.2
Superb
8 reviews
Price from
US$80.75
per night

Cozy Nesting is located in Bay Shore, 31 km from Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum, 37 km from Jones Beach State Park, and 37 km from Nikon Theater. The homestay provides rooms with air conditioning, free private parking and free WiFi. Easy to check in, very clean, total worth it

Show more Show less
9.6
Exceptional
5 reviews

Offering a garden and garden view, ZenOasis pvt BedBath Studio by NUMC is situated in East Meadow, 17 km from Jones Beach State Park and 18 km from Nikon Theater. This property offers access to a patio, free private parking and free WiFi. The property is non-smoking and is located 6 km from Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum. The host was available and very helpful. Whatever I unexpectedly needed was available. Nice shower. Easy access, and great location. Pretty garden view. Lots of windows, that opened. We highly recommend it and would book it again

Show more Show less
9.1
Superb
14 reviews
Price from
US$114
per night

The Pines Men-Only Stay is a recently renovated homestay in Fire Island Pines, where guests can make the most of its outdoor swimming pool and terrace. A fitness room is available for guests, along with a solarium. The homestay has private entrance. Absolute gem in the Pines 🌊🔥 From the moment we arrived, this property delivered the kind of stay you hope for on Fire Island and rarely get all at once. The home is gorgeous—immaculately kept, stylish without trying too hard—and the heated pool became our daily ritual. Beds? Massive, cloud-level comfortable. We slept like babies after sunset boardwalk strolls. There’s also a proper gym on site, so we could offset all the “vacation decisions” we made at dinner. 😅 What really sets this place apart is the host. Warm, proactive, genuinely thoughtful—the kind of hospitality that feels effortless because it’s real. He even made me an iced coffee (I’m usually not a fan) that was so good I asked for the recipe. Communication was smooth end-to-end and check-in/check-out were a breeze. If you’re debating where to stay in the Pines, this is your sign. Beautiful property, heated pool, huge comfy beds, gym for the motivated—and a host who turns a great trip into an unforgettable one. We’ll be back. 🇿🇦❤️

Show more Show less
9.4
Superb
49 reviews
Price from
US$168
per night

The Madison Fire Island Pines in Fire Island Pines provides adults-only accommodation with an outdoor swimming pool and a terrace. Featuring pool and garden views, this guest house also includes free WiFi. I’ve seen other reviews and this they completely undersell this property. It is beautiful, has an excellent location (1 min from FIP ferry) and the facilities, especially the Japanese garden and pool, are stunning. Another review complained about bathroom products; they now have Malin+Goetz, which is a luxury brand. And one mentioned the staff wasn’t friendly: Mike was excellent, made us breakfast, and sangria, so either it was an off day or the customer. Overall, this is the only place I want to stay in FIP.

Show more Show less
9
Superb
13 reviews
Price from
US$184
per night

Situated within 9.3 km of Belmont Park Race Track and 11 km of Aqueduct Racetrack, Abby's Comfort in North Woodmere features a terrace and rooms with free WiFi. The property is set 17 km from Arthur Ashe Stadium, 19 km from Citi Field and 20 km from Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum. Nikon Theater is 27 km away and Coney Island is 28 km from the homestay. The accommodation was clean and very pleasant to stay in. The host was also most welcoming and helpful!

Show more Show less
8.4
Very good
24 reviews
Price from
US$85.50
per night

The homestay comes with a flat-screen TV. Towels and bed linen are provided in the homestay. The accommodation offers an air conditioning, a heating and a shared bathroom.

Aqueduct Racetrack is 16 km from the homestay, while Bronx Zoo is 24 km away. John F. Kennedy International Airport is 12 km from the property. The host was incredibly responsive and accommodating. The accommodation was well situated and a walkable distance to everything you needed.

Show more Show less
8.3
Very good
10 reviews
Price from
US$103.28
per night

Situated 22 km from Belmont Park Race Track, 22 km from Jones Beach State Park and 22 km from Nikon Theater, Modern Chic CoCo Chanel Inspired * Biz Friendly * Close To All offers accommodation located in Hicksville. Both free WiFi and parking on-site are accessible at the homestay free of charge. The property is allergy-free and is set 10 km from Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum.

Show more Show less
8
Very good
6 reviews
Price from
US$109
per night

At the homestay, every unit comes with a wardrobe and a flat-screen TV. There is a private bathroom with hot tub in some units, along with bathrobes, slippers and free toiletries. At the homestay, all units are fitted with bed linen and towels. Very quiet and clean. Bed was very comfortable

Show more Show less
5
Review score
8 reviews
Price from
US$144
per night

The spacious homestay has a flat-screen TV. Towels and bed linen are available in the homestay. The accommodation offers an air conditioning, a heating and a shared bathroom.

United Nations Headquarters is 27 km from the homestay, while Jones Beach State Park is 28 km from the property. John F. Kennedy International Airport is 11 km away.

Show more Show less
9.7
Exceptional
4 reviews
Price from
US$113.99
per night

Most booked homestays in Long Island this month

FAQs about homestays in Long Island

Homestays that guests love in Long Island